Sign up for e-mail updates:

Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Sections
Personal tools
You are here: Home ›› Blog ›› Gravel Mine Proposed for Salmon River Stirs Up Questions

Gravel Mine Proposed for Salmon River Stirs Up Questions

Posted by Jonathan Oppenheimer at Jan 18, 2012 04:20 PM |

The Idaho Conservation League—and others—are raising concerns to the State of Idaho over a proposed gravel mine operation in the bed of the Salmon River.

Gravel Mine Proposed for Salmon River Stirs Up Questions

Gravel mining in the Salmon River significantly impacts water quality, streamside vegetation and fish. IDWR photo.

(WHITE BIRD) - The Idaho Conservation League and others are raising concerns to the State of Idaho over a proposed gravel mine operation in the bed of the Salmon River.

The Idaho Land Board is being asked to issue a lease for gravel mining below the high water mark of the main stem of the Salmon River near White Bird, north of Riggins. The Salmon River is the second largest river in Idaho, and the source of clean water, habitat for salmon and steelhead, and recreation including boating and fishing. The public comment period ends Saturday, January 21.

“Thousands of people come to Idaho each year to enjoy the Salmon River. As a river guide, I sell a chance for folks to get away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. They want to experience the sights and sounds of nature—not heavy industrial equipment gouging the Salmon River,” said Gary Lane, owner and lead guide of Wapiti River Guides in Riggins.

Technically, the mining technique is called “gravel bar scalping,” where miners use heavy equipment such as bulldozers and loaders to mine and haul away gravel deposited by high spring flows.

“Research has shown that gravel mining in streams and rivers can harm fisheries and aquatic habitat. Instead, we should use other sources of gravel, and protect Idaho's valuable water resources for future generations of Idahoans," said Dr. Jennifer Pierce, a Boise State University geomorphology professor who has studied the effects of in-stream mining on rivers throughout the Pacific Northwest.

Potential impacts of this kind of mining include increased downstream erosion and sedimentation, plus the accidental release of fuels, lubricants and other industrial fluids. Streamside habitats are among the most biologically rich in Idaho, and the Salmon River in particular is a destination for anglers, hunters and river rafters. The section of the Salmon River being proposed for mining contains designated critical habitat for endangered species including spring and fall chinook salmon, steelhead, and bull trout. Fall chinook salmon, in particular, have been documented to spawn in close proximity to the mining operation.

“The Salmon River is a precious natural resource important to many Idahoans,” said Jonathan Oppenheimer, senior conservation associate with the Idaho Conservation League. “There are many places to appropriately mine gravel in Idaho—within the banks of the Salmon River just isn’t one of them.”

Oppenheimer and other concerned Idahoans are urging the state to reject the proposal and implement protections for the Salmon River, consistent with its iconic status.

Contact:   
Jonathan Oppenheimer, Idaho Conservation League, 208-345-6942 ext. 26


Document Actions

Salmon River Gravel Mining

Posted by CR Bob Hickey at Jan 23, 2012 10:25 AM
Growing up on the Idaho/Oregon border I have enjoyed this water way my entire life, over 50 years. There has to be an intelligent answer to not disturb this habitat and fishery.

Salmon River Gravel

Posted by Scott Nichols at Jan 25, 2012 10:17 AM
This is the kind of operation ICL should support! The operation has been working on the site for more than 25 years without impacting fisheries or water quality. The project supports at least one family maybe more and keeps untold truckloads of gravel from being hualed from more distant sources. Let's demonstrate some middle ground and support utilizing this renewable resource!

Salmon River Gravel

Posted by Jonathan Oppenheimer, ICL at Jan 25, 2012 03:54 PM
@Scott Nichols, We do not dispute the fact that this operation has been working on this site for decades, however there has never been any site-specific evaluation of the impacts on fisheries or water quality or downstream erosion, to name a few. That's exactly what we're asking for. Instead of rubber-stamping this lease renewal, we feel that a thorough review is required, and consultation with US Fish and Wildlife Service and NOAA-Fisheries is necessary to evaluate impacts to designated critical habitat for fish that migrate through and spawn in the direct vicinity of this industrial operation.
After all, a lot has changed since this gravel mine was initially approved, including the designation of critical habitat, determination of eligible Wild and Scenic River, ESA-listing of at least 5 species of fish in the direct vicinity, and reams of research on the negative impacts of these types of operations.
While we do not dismiss the concern over lost revenue to Mr. Kaschmitter or Salmon River Rock Products, our understanding is that this corporation has access to multiple upland locations for gravel and this site has not even been excavated since 2009. We are confident that alternative sites could be developed with lesser impacts that would protect the outstanding value that we, and many Idahoans, place on the Salmon River.

powered by Plone | site by Groundwire and served with clean energy